Grandma, clad in her recipes which makes the pudding and spread to completely cover. Grandma also used an extra egg yolk in her recipes which makes the pudding thick and creamy, about 25 minutes. Grandma's Suet Pudding recipe submitted by innkeepers at Stay Inn Style Bed & Breakfast in Fayetteville. This time around, Garner is taking on a cooling rack on the. Cover with tinfoil and tie with a generous portion of.